This
page makes use of an innovation of mine called 'dual-purpose text.' Click
anywhere in the text below (not in the white space around the text) to get
to the top of the page very quickly and easily - there's no need to find a
separate top button or to scroll. The page on Web design describes this innovation
and others, including 'the rail,' which can also be used to reach top of page.
Text links, to reach different sections of this long page, are shown as underlined
below, but not in colour.
As well as developing the new technique of linkage
by meaning, I've developed new techniques in rhymed poetry (an instance
of linkage by sound): new and complex rhyme schemes, but,
more importantly, such innovations as centred
rhyme and the sound gradient. I also use
repeated rhyme and rearrangement
of rhyme. In addition, I give a defence
of rhyme as a technique in contemporary poetry.
The use of rhyme can have a beneficial
effect on a poet’s technique. It sets a challenge. Since rhyme can have
a mechanical effect and has associations from the past, the onus is on the
poet to avoid these pitfalls by deflecting attention from the ends of lines,
by using rhythmic subtlety and by using a diction which is not at all dated
or hackneyed (always remembering that modern diction of a certain kind will
quickly become dated.) A distinctively modern procedure in rhymed poetry is
to establish a linkage by sound and at the same time to make the linkage not
an obvious one, even to deflect attention away from the linkage. Alternatively,
there may be a tension between the obviousness of the rhyme and the unexpected
diction.
Some kinds of poetry seem almost to
demand the use of rhyme, for example, humorous and light poetry. It would
be difficult to name a large number of humorous and light poems in free verse,
in 'language poetry' or so-called 'linguistically innovative poetry.' Some
examples from my own work:
The Inquisition
On the rack they are highered.
At the stake they are fired.
And all because of
simple, clerical errors.
Or in a poem whose first few lines only
I give here:
The worst restaurant in the
world
In this caff we serve them right.
Yesterday, someone asked for wholemeal bread.
I gave him stale, sliced white
and shouted in his ear, "Stuff it up your stupid...
(These two poems are due to be published in print form,
in the magazine of humorous verse 'Krax.')
The past associations of rhyme, the
past associations of other literary techniques, quotation or near-quotation
from a writer of the past, should not always be avoided in a contemporary
poem. Modern squalor can be vividly realized by contrasting it with past beauty.
Eliot did exactly this in The Waste Land, and made the contrast more effective
by the allusion to Spencer: ‘Sweet Thames, run softly till I end my
song.’ There are many other contrasts which would show past ages rather
than our own in an unflattering light, and which would have the effect of
making Eliot’s viewpoint over-simple.
Rhyme can create a disturbance. It can
express a disturbing vision. It is also a way of creating contrast. In the
study of rhyme, attention has been focussed on the line endings linked by
rhyme, but also important is the contrast between what rhymes and what does
not rhyme. In general, when a linkage is established, a contrast is also established.
This poem patterned by sound is surely a fully contemporary poem:
THE ELECTRIC CHAIR
The silence silences, as if to explain.
Caught, and now, caught again,
caught up with by the past,
after ten years here, at last.
The end crowns the work.
The witnesses are like this poor waxwork,
as if them the crown was designed to kill,
but even more, shockingly, still,
until his, despite the straps,
nervous twitching stops,
then some suddenly gasp, like him.
Of the rich purple and scarlet trim
of the blotches and the trickle of blood
nothing can yet be seen, or should.
To shudder, to think
they leave - as they leave - unlinked.
(35s)
(A technique I sometimes use is the insertion of a punctuation
mark such as a comma in a common phrase, altering its significance. In the
poem above, the common phrase 'To shudder to think' becomes 'To shudder, to
think...')
The next poem appears in a variant form, as a 'picture poem,'
in the page on 'Linkages with art and design.' The poem undergoes fragmentation
in the picture space. Fragmentation gives a poem which is more 'contemporary'
than the unfragmented poem.
SAILING FROM BELFAST
I climb up and down slopping stairs.
The upper deck’s awash with brine,
like the floor of a urinal flooded with urine.
The pitching ship pushes through pitch-black night.
We yawn and vomit, yawn and vomit,
with faces flushed stagger speechless from the toilet.
Plastic coffee cups roll along the floor,
backwards and forwards, backwards and forwards,
like this ship, condemned to sail from and towards
Belfast, Liverpool; Northern Ireland, England.
On this wild night, as our ship shudders and sinks
and rises again and again, I give thanks
and feel hope, groundless, indestructible hope.
By morning light, the sea has moderated, the waves raked,
the shrieking lies behind us, we queue to separate.
The green of Ulster fields, the orange of Ulster sunsets
are fading, distant. In the grey dawn, the pleasure of
feeling
nothing.
(62s)
D-day
The calm, blue sea of sky
which saturates the land with light
no longer separates the drifting island
of the sun from the drifting continent's mainland.
Glittering shoals of stars swim in the
crashing deeper sky, constantly
replenished and netted and landed,
brought to the land exactly when demanded.
The land masses above and below
and is your landing, outlandish, and so
like a landed fish you'll gasp
at what you cannot hope or fail to grasp.
I only explain some of the allusions here. The poem makes a contrast between
the regularity and predictability of nature and the unpredictable experience
when the troops land on a D-day beach for the invasion. The orbits of the
stars can be predicted by means of scientific theories. The philosopher of
science Karl Popper compared these theories to 'nets:' ""Theories
are nets cast to catch what we call 'the world': to rationalize, to explain,
and to master it. We endeavour to make the mesh ever finer and finer."
The stars (which are constantly replenishing themselves by nuclear reactions)
sink in their apparent motions towards the land ('are landed') when predicted
by theory. The sun's apparent motion through the sky is its drifting, but
withdrawing associations of aimlessness. This is a technique which I sometimes
use - insisting on some of the associations of a word or phrase, deliberately
excluding others. The drifting of the mainland is an aspect of continental
drift.
Compare this poem with a poem I read a long time after writing it (I can
be completely certain about this): Yeats' poem 'Three Movements,' from 'The
Winding Stair and Other Poems:'
Shakespearean fish swam in the sea, far away from land;
Romantic fish swam in nets coming to the land;
What are all those fish that lie gasping on the strand?
The next poem I quote, a poem which
gives voice to the sufferings caused by The Industrial Revolution, isn't a
fully contemporary poem in itself. It may be that its technique is appropriate
to the evocation of a remote era.
Snow fell, as soft as soot, for days,
then dense fog settled deep, the familiar, mysterious mass
that went on and on and made their streets a maze.
Constantly, the melodramatic hiss of gas.
Days divided into dark and after-dark,
days full of cold on the chest, congested, stained.
Dogs despaired, cats starved, stark
horses dragged carts piled with silk, stained.
From time to time, a child looked up from the factory loom
and when the fog for a moment covered less,
looked deeply through the window into the gloom
and caught, coughing, a glimpse like a glimpse of happiness,
of the street and the hard canal staggering alike
under loads of icing and satin snow,
and of boot and clog prints, the imprint of bare feet,
like
long stitches in graceful loops, daring the snow
from the street to the far bank of the canal and back.
The poem contains a form of alliteration
which I call diversified alliteration: the common device
of alliteration is extended by diversification.
(For 'diversification,' please see the General Glossary.) Alliteration is
first generalized and then particularized. Alliteration is regarded as an
instance of the general principle of linkage by sound and then other particular
instances of the general principle are derived. In alliteration the initial
letter is repeated. In line 7 of the poem below the variant instance
makes use of not one letter but two letters and not the initial two
letters but the final two letters of 'cats.' The letters 'ts' are inverted
and the resulting invert, 'st' appears as the initial sound of 'starved.'
Alliteration then follows, with the use of 'stark' following 'starved.' The
'st' sound has been anticipated by use of the word 'stained' in line 6 and
the sound is confirmed by use of the word 'stained' in line 8.
If conventional alliteration is a hackneyed
device, unsuitable for contemporary poetry, alliteration can still be used
in a contemporary way. One possibility is to use alliteration in a way which
is excessive. Deliberate excess as a technique in contemporary poetry I refer
to as 'nimiety.' An example is the use of a poem in unit form which is not
given on this site, 'The Matterhorn,' in which every word begins with the
letter 'w' except for the one word 'once,' a sustained exercise in alliteration
which is intended to be more than just an exercise. The term 'nimiety' is
used by Coleridge. It's applied by Basil Lam in his study of the Beethoven
String Quartets, with reference to a repeated phrase in the Quartet Opus 135.
It can be applied to the whole of Beethoven's Grosse Fuge, Opus 133.
Technically, this poem concerned with
The Industrial Revolution is given additional contemporary resonance by its
intended use: the poem is intended to be superimposed on a painting which
makes use of the technique of Colour Stain Painting introduced by Helen Frankenthaler
and a development of Colour Field Painting, the technique of soaking paint
which has been diluted into the unprimed canvas. The use of the word 'stained'
in lines 6 and 8 is relevant. As regards content, the poem does exemplify
the principles of linkage and harsh contrast, in this case, the contrast of
luxurious associations and poverty.
(65s)
Rhyme can be used in an unsystematic way as well as a systematic
way, just as words are linked in an unsystematic way in thematic word
linkage. The rhymed words provide markers in the poem. So, pattern
by sound may be either formal or non-formal.
Centred
rhyme
There is no need for a poet to be dependent upon established rhyme schemes.
Here, too, there is scope for innovation. In centred rhyme, the first line
rhymes with the last, the second line with the penultimate, and so on, until
at the centre of the poem there are two adjacent lines which rhyme, or, alternatively,
a single line which rhymes with no other.
This can be shown by means of two linkage
diagrams. I use square brackets to show the linkage of rhymed lines, curved
brackets to show the linkage of lines within a meaning pattern.
The rhymes at the centre and near the
centre will be prominent, the effect becoming fainter as we move towards the
top and bottom margins of the poem. There will be a sound gradient from the
centre to these margins, lines which are distant from the centre hardly being
perceived as rhyming. This technique gives a method of varying the impact
of rhyme. If the rhymes at the centre are disturbing, there will be a disturbance
at the heart of the poem which gradually dies away.
Please click here for an
example of a poem in centred rhyme. This poem is discussed more fully
in the page on Concrete Poetry. The rhyme scheme is: d c b
a a b c d
The distance between rhymes is an important
consideration not only in centred rhyme but also in other contemporary poetry
which is patterned by sound. When words at the ends of lines rhyme, the two
variables which must be considered are distance apart - the rhyme
interval - and degree (directness and obviousness
or otherwise of the rhyme.) If ‘dear’ is rhymed, in a very direct
way, with ‘hear’ and the rhymes are at the ends of adjacent lines,
then this can be described as dear, hear (2). The figure in curved brackets
refers to the interval between lines. (I use a different notation for rhymes
within the lines.) Rhymes which are proximate as well as direct are often,
but not always, inappropriate in a contemporary poem. If the rhymed words
are separated by two intervening lines, ie dear, hear (4), then the rhymes
can still be described as proximate and less direct. More likely to be useful
in a fully contemporary poem are dear, hear (8), where the rhymes are linked
and separated more widely (the interval is greater), and dear, dare (2). In
a poem in centred rhyme, more direct rhymes may be employed in the periphery
of the poem (for example, in the first and last lines) and less direct rhymes
may be used in the central lines, aa in the sound scheme above. This modifies
the sound gradient, introducing tension.
Repeated
rhyme
I sometimes use 'rhyme clusters.' Here,
the rhyme interval (within the line) is very short - the rhymes are adjoining.
An example is the beginning of a poem -
Useless - less - unless distress
drives or drove your work.
Useless - less - unless success...
This is a further example of 'nimiety,'
discussed above.
Rearrangement
of rhyme
The syntax of a poem can be adjusted
in order to reduce the rhyme interval. Rhymes become closer, as in this example:
He wrote
purely, by rote,
and said that he,
and said that we,
will always convince,
will be convinced by -
his daring
us to be unconvinced.
As will be obvious, 'he' is brought
into close rhyme with 'we.' I refer to this technique as rearrangement
of rhyme. Two lines are separated from their natural successors.
The words 'and said that he' have as their successor 'will always
convince' but they have been separated from it. The words 'and said that we'
have as natural successor 'will be convinced by' but likewise are separated
from it. The regrouping has the effect of making the rhyme more direct by
reducing the interval.
Rearrangement is a
technique which is more generally applicable and which need not entail the
use of rhyme. It makes the close more distant and the distant closer. It may
produce phrases which are rhythmic 'thumps,' concentrated rhythmic clusters,
ending the poem decisively or giving greater impact to the whole poem. Restoration
gives the syntax and the word order of non-poetic prose. In the example above,
restoration gives the sense, 'and said that he/will always convince' and 'and
said that we/ will be convinced by.'
In the next example, the rhymes are
not proximate. The rhyme interval is 3, 'upon' rhyming with 'gone'. Rearrangement
of the syntax in this case separates four lines from their four successors,
producing a concentrated final line containing all the successors. Some contemporary
poetry abandons meaning - for good reason, and successfully, or otherwise.
Martin Seymour-Smith, in his remarkable work, 'Guide to Modern World Literature,'
writes of John Ashbery, "...a critic shrewdly wrote of him (1978) that
he 'eliminates meaning without achieving any special intensity.' Perhaps what
we all truly long for is a poetry of coherence, rather than meaning."
The poem below only appears to abandon meaning.
C S Lewis
Surprised by
and upon
and surrendered
and gone -
joy, imposed, reason, Callus.
Restoring the syntax makes the meaning
clear, or almost clear - in the case of this poem, some background information
is needed. (I defend very robustly the idea that some poems should absolutely
require background information. I oppose resolutely the notion that a poem
has always to be 'self-sufficient,' needing no external explanation.) C S
Lewis had three distinct careers - as scholar, as children's writer and as
Christian apologist. It's only in his third role that I find him repulsive.
My objection is not to do with his defence of Christianity as such but to
its manner - shallow and, in part, callous. (He writes in 'Mere Christianity,
"If you had committed a murder, the right Christian thing to do would
be to give yourself up to the police and be hanged." C S Lewis is an
apologist for the gallows as well as for Christianity, then.) After restoring
the syntax, we have:
'Surprised by joy,' the title of the
autobiographical book by Lewis in which he recounts his adoption of Christianity.
'Imposed upon.' The unfavourable associations
of this phrase are many.
'Reason surrendered.' Lewis would have
claimed that he didn't exchange reason for faith but the reasoning in his
theological books is so tawdry and inadequate that the phrase can easily be
justified.
'Gone, the callus.' Lewis is compared
with a callus, something that is thick, hard, insensitive, but now no longer
with us.
Another poem of mine illustrates the
same principles, although in a much quieter way. In this case, there are two
successors to red (below) and blue (above): the red colour in the poem is
contracting, the blue is expanding.
It is not even, evening.
Below, a glow -
red, redder, reddest,
above, sky-blue,
contracts, expands,
like the lives in the houses in the forest -
receptive, shuttered and almost invisible now,
awaiting blue-fingered night.
('Blue-fingered' - the night being very
cold - is an allusion to Homer's 'rosy-fingered dawn.') 'Contract, expand'
gain in force and contrast by being placed next to each other. Restoration
gives a version which has less impact:
Below, a glow -
red, redder, reddest,
contracts,
above, sky-blue,
expands ...
Word-chains (or 'concatenations')
often emerge as a result of rearrangement. An example above is 'joy, imposed,
reason, Callus.' Just as a chain is strong, a word-chain should be strong,
or, more exactly, have semantic force. (This term is explained further in
the entry for 'Evaluative Linguistics' in the General Glossary.) This word-chain
is not part of a poem, and not part of of a potential poem: 'Remarkable, neglected,
unjustly, long.' The reference is to Martin Seymour-Smith's Guide, cited above.
The concise word-chain surely has greater impact than the restored, slightly
amplified equivalent, Martin-Seymour's Guide is a 'remarkable, lengthy work
which is unjustly neglected, and has been neglected for a long time.'
Several lines may have one, common successor,
not several successors, as in this example, where the successor is in the
final line.
In -
or out of -
or severe -
or very near -
danger.
So, 'In -' doesn't have its own unique
successor, it has the same successor as the next lines: 'danger.' Restoration
gives 'In danger,' 'or out of danger...'
Poetic language is often more sensuous
than non-poetic language, as, almost always, in Keats, but it may also be
more schematic than non-poetic language. This schematic language will sometimes
seem abstract and sometimes bare and elemental, powerful and direct rather
than abstract. Cezanne's practice gives strong support for schematism. Cezanne
took the human body, a still life or landscape (above all, Mont Sainte-Victoire
in Provence) and distorted appearances and modified tonality in order to achieve
a pictorial balance, but, more than that, a 'realm of pure being.' (Richard
Verdi: 'Cezanne.') George Heard Hamilton refers to Cezanne's 'organizing intelligence.'
('Painting and Sculpture in Europe 1880-1940')
The meaning of sound patterns
Pattern by meaning and pattern by sound
may both be used in the same poem, and lines which are linked by sound may
be linked at the same time by meaning. These linkages would be shown by using
both square and round brackets. Studies of the meanings of rhymed words in
a poem would form a useful study. ‘Love’ rhymes with ‘dove,’
and also with ‘shove,’ but obviously the meaning linkages are
completely dissimilar.